Weaknesses and inherent difficulties of liberal democracy
XAT 2026 · VALR · Hard · Reading Comprehension
Passage / data set
Read the following passage and answer the THREE questions that follow.
As the post-World War II generation of liberal democratic leaders forged new, highly successful domestic and international institutions and policies throughout the West, the weaknesses of liberal democracy that dominated the two decades after World War I faded from view. But they did not disappear.
First, because liberal democracy restrains majorities, it slows the achievement of goals that majorities support. This generates frustration with institutional restraints, and an unacknowledged envy of authoritarian systems that can act quickly and decisively. China can build huge cities in the time that it takes the United States to review the environmental impact of small highway projects. Liberal democracy requires more patience than many possess.
Second, liberal democracy requires tolerance for minority views and ways of life to which many citizens are deeply opposed. It is natural to feel that if we consider certain views or ways of life to be odious, we should use public power to suppress them. In many such cases, liberal democracy requires us to restrain this impulse, a psychological burden that some will find unbearable.
This leads directly to the third inherent problem of liberal democracy—the distinction it requires us to make between civic identity and personal or group identity. For example, although we may consider certain religious views false and even dangerous, we must, for civic purposes, accept those who hold these views as our equals. They may freely express these views; they may organize to promote them; they may vote, and their votes are given the same weight as ours. The same goes for race, ethnicity, gender, and all the particularities that distinguish us from one another.
This requirement often goes against the grain of natural sentiments. We want the public sphere to reflect what we find most valuable about our private commitments. Liberal democracy prevents us from fully translating our personal identities into our public lives as citizens. This too is not always easy to bear. The quest for wholeness—for a political community, or even a world, that reflects our most important commitments—is a deep yearning to which illiberal leaders can always appeal.
Nor is the fourth inherent difficulty of liberal democracy—the necessity of compromise—easy to bear. If what I want is good and true, why should I agree that public decisions must incorporate competing views? James Madison gives us the answer: in circumstances of liberty, diversity of views is inevitable, and unless those who agree with us form a majority so large as to be irresistible, the alternative to compromise is inaction, which is often more damaging, or oppression, which always is.
Question 1 of 3
According to the passage, which of the following BEST explains why liberal democracy needs patience?
- A.
Because liberal democracy at its core is more conservative.
- B.
Because liberal democracy has to ensure that all views are considered before taking a decision.
- C.
Because liberal democratic institutions that enable protection of minorities restrain majorities from acting unilaterally.
- D.
Because liberal democracy believes that minority views matter more than majority views.
- E.
Because liberal democracy believes environmental impact is more important than human progress.
Question 2 of 3
According to the passage, how does the second problem of liberal democracy lead to the third problem?
- A.
While some find certain views personally distasteful, they will permit those views to exist in the public sphere.
- B.
The more we find some views unacceptable, the more liberal democracy forces us to accept it in a public space.
- C.
We tolerate unpopular views since the view holder has a right to express and follow them.
- D.
By tolerating the views we disagree with, we suffer from multiple identities.
- E.
While we tolerate views that we disagree with, we have to demonstrate that we tolerate them by allowing them to coexist among us.
Question 3 of 3
According to the passage, which of the following reasons BEST explains why "necessity of compromise" is a difficulty for liberal democracy?
- A.
We do not like compromising on anything we badly want.
- B.
Since our core beliefs define who we are, we want to see that reflected in public space.
- C.
Liberal democracy makes us endure divergent behaviours in public sphere.
- D.
While we believe our views are correct, to accept that others' views deserve merit is not always easy.
- E.
Since liberal democracy is supposed to protect our rights, compromising on them seems incompatible with liberty.
Practise this under exam conditions
Sign in to solve it with a live timer, the on-screen CAT calculator, and streak and accuracy tracking across every question you attempt.
Solve in the workspace